Technical comparison of power systems

CTTS and STS: differences and the role of an online UPS

CTTS and STS systems transfer the load between two sources. An online UPS performs a different function: it powers the load through an inverter and temporarily draws on the energy stored in its battery. In an integrated system, the ATS transfers the UPS input to the generator set, while the UPS supports the critical load during generator starting and stabilisation.

Brief answer

CTTS and STS have two inputs and can transfer the load only to a second source that is available and within acceptable limits. For closed transition, both sources must be available and acceptable at the same time. The CTTS monitors voltage, frequency and phase-angle differences, waits for the sources to enter the specified synchronism window and then performs a planned transfer with 0 ms interruption of supply. Continuous source synchronism is not required. By contrast, to guarantee an emergency STS transfer in 2–9 ms, its two sources must remain continuously synchronised: the active-source failure cannot be predicted, so the STS cannot wait for synchronism after the fault. If synchronism is absent, fast transfer is inhibited or performed with a delay; in terms of the effect on the load, the STS loses its advantage over a conventional ATS. An online UPS does not replace the ATS: it temporarily powers the load from a battery with a finite energy reserve. In a generator-backed system, the UPS supports the load while the generator starts, and the ATS connects it to the UPS input.

Unsure which architecture you need? Describe the sources, load and permissible interruption: a STAVR engineer will help determine whether you need CTTS, STS or an ATS combined with an online UPS.

Request technical selection

1. Why these systems are confused

CTTS and STS perform a switching function: they monitor two AC sources and connect the load to one of them. Neither device has its own stored energy. If the second source is absent or unacceptable, there is nowhere to transfer the load.

An online UPS performs an energy-supply function: its inverter supports the load from the DC link and battery when the incoming utility supply fails. However, this mode is limited by the available autonomy. Once the battery is discharged, power will also be lost unless another AC source is connected to the UPS input.

The key distinction: an ATS, CTTS or STS selects the source, whereas a UPS bridges the period when no source is yet available. For a utility–generator arrangement, the correct architecture therefore places the ATS upstream of the UPS: the battery supports the critical load while the generator starts, after which the UPS continues operating from generator power.

2. CTTS and STS operating principles and the role of an online UPS

CTTS

Mechanical contacts

A Closed Transition Transfer Switch connects the new source before disconnecting the previous one. The sources briefly operate in parallel, so the control system checks voltage, frequency, phase sequence and the phase angle between the sources before transfer. The CTTS does not synchronise the sources; it waits until they enter the specified synchronism window naturally. For example, with ASCO Closed Transition, the magnitude of the phase-angle difference must be less than 5° (within ±5°), the frequency difference less than 0.2 Hz and the voltage difference less than 5%; for other models, the limits are specified by the manufacturer.

STS

Semiconductor switches

A Static Transfer Switch uses power thyristors or other semiconductor switches. It disconnects the unacceptable input and connects an acceptable second input using the break-before-make principle. Because a fault can occur at any moment, guaranteed transfer in 2–9 ms requires the STS sources to remain continuously synchronised and the controller to continuously confirm acceptable voltage, frequency and phase-angle differences. If synchronism is lost, fast switching is inhibited and a delay is introduced before the load can be safely reconnected.

Online UPS

Double conversion

The incoming AC voltage is converted to DC, and the inverter converts it back to AC for the load. The battery is connected to the DC link. In a typical integrated arrangement, the UPS receives the source already selected by the ATS, whether utility or generator, and does not perform the function of an external ATS.

Comparison of CTTS, STS and online UPS operating principles: planned CTTS transfer, emergency STS transfer and battery-backed supply through an online UPS
CTTS and STS switch between external AC sources, whereas an online UPS supports the load through its inverter and DC link. Practical CTTS solutions →

3. What happens when the active source suddenly fails

CTTS

If the active source has already failed, the second source cannot be connected before the first source is lost: the first source is effectively no longer available. The CTTS waits for the standby source to become available and ready, then performs a conventional transfer with an interruption. In a utility–generator arrangement, generator starting and stabilisation time adds to this interruption.

Therefore: CTTS does not require continuous synchronism and does not itself synchronise the sources. For a planned closed-transition transfer, both sources must be available and acceptable simultaneously; the controller waits for them to enter the specified synchronism window and only then transfers without interrupting the supply. If the active source has already failed, only open-transition transfer is possible. If both sources are present but the synchronism window has not been reached, closed transition is delayed or inhibited according to the controller settings.

STS

The STS detects that the active input is unacceptable, stops conduction from it and connects an acceptable alternative input. If no acceptable second source exists, the STS cannot support the load. If the standby source was synchronised with the active source at the moment of the fault, transfer takes approximately 2–9 ms with a minimal phase jump.

In practice, industrial loads are mixed. In addition to motors and transformers, they include switch-mode power supplies, rectifiers, variable-frequency drives and inverters with charged DC buses. An abrupt phase change can cause an input-capacitor recharge pulse, a current surge, loss of synchronisation in an electronic converter, protective-device operation or an overload of the STS power thyristors.

If the STS sources are not synchronised: fast transfer is not used in a general industrial arrangement. For motors, a delay of approximately 3–5 s is provided to allow residual EMF to decay. However, a delay does not eliminate every risk: after the DC buses discharge, simultaneous reconnection of switch-mode power supplies, inverters and variable-frequency drives can produce a high combined inrush current. The STS surge overload capability must therefore also be checked, inrush calculated and, where necessary, load groups connected in stages. Structurally, the device remains a solid-state transfer switch, but its effect on the load is that of an ATS with an interruption.

Online UPS

In double-conversion mode, the inverter continues to power the load from the DC link, while the battery compensates for the loss of incoming energy. Transfer to battery therefore takes zero time. However, autonomy is limited: if the utility supply does not return and the ATS does not supply generator power to the UPS input before the battery is discharged, the output voltage will be lost.

4. Comparison table

CriterionCTTSSTSOnline UPS
Primary functionControlled transfer between two sources, including uninterrupted supply during a permitted transferFast selection of one of two independent AC sourcesContinuous, regulated power to the load
External sourcesTwo monitored inputsTwo monitored inputsIn a typical arrangement, one input already selected by the ATS; the battery is a temporary internal energy source. A separate bypass input does not make the UPS a substitute for an external ATS
Power switching elementElectromechanical contactsSemiconductor switches, predominantly thyristorsRectifier, DC link, inverter, battery and static bypass
Parallel source operationYes, momentarily during closed transitionNo; typical operation is break-before-makeNot the principle used to supply the load; the sources are separated by power converters
Phase-alignment monitoringContinuous synchronism is not required. For closed transition, the controller must detect that two available, acceptable sources have entered the specified voltage, frequency and phase-angle difference windowTo guarantee an emergency transfer in 2–9 ms, both sources must remain continuously synchronised and the STS must continuously monitor voltage, frequency and phase-angle differencesNot a condition for transfer to battery: the inverter continuously supplies the load
Planned transfer0 ms interruption of supply when both sources are available, acceptable and within the specified synchronism windowBetween synchronised sources, typically 2–9 ms. Without synchronism, a design-specified delay is required, approximately 3–5 sDoes not transfer the load between two external sources; this is the function of the ATS upstream of the UPS
Transfer following sudden input failureWith an interruption; for a generator set, after starting and stabilisationApproximately 2–9 ms if the standby source is acceptable and synchronised with the active source at the moment of failure. Without synchronism, a delay is required until safe load reconnection is possible0 ms to battery in double-conversion mode
Stored energyNoneNoneYes, in a battery or another DC energy-storage device
Voltage-quality correctionNo; the load receives the electrical characteristics of the selected sourceNo; the load receives the electrical characteristics of the selected sourceYes; the inverter generates the output voltage within the UPS specifications
Typical loadsIndustrial, commercial and infrastructure loads. For a planned, uninterrupted transfer between two generator sets, the CTTS monitors voltage, frequency and phase angle, waits for both sources to enter the specified synchronism window and then performs closed transitionSingle-input critical loads with two independent, conditioned sources availableServers, control systems, communications, medical equipment and other loads that cannot tolerate an interruption
Main limitationUninterrupted transfer is possible when both sources are available and acceptable simultaneously and the CTTS detects that they have entered the specified synchronism window. Continuous source synchronism is not requiredTwo continuously synchronised, acceptable sources are required. Without synchronism, fast transfer in 2–9 ms is lost; a delay and checks of inrush and STS surge capability are required, and the effect on the load is that of an ATS with an interruptionOnce battery energy is exhausted, power is lost unless the ATS connects the utility supply or generator; batteries require maintenance

5. Typical appropriate combinations

ATS / CTTS + online UPS + generator setThe ATS monitors the utility supply and generator and connects the selected source to the UPS input. When utility power fails, the UPS switches to battery operation without interruption and supports the critical load. The generator set starts and stabilises its voltage and frequency, after which the ATS connects it to the UPS. The UPS then supplies the load using generator power and recharges the battery.
UPS redundancy: two UPS units + STSThe outputs of two independent UPS units provide two conditioned, continuously synchronised AC sources for the STS. Single-input critical equipment is supplied from one of them; if the active UPS fails, the transfer switch connects the load to the healthy standby UPS. This architecture provides UPS redundancy and removes the load's dependence on a single power path.
STS without UPSAn STS is primarily used for emergency transfer between two independent, continuously synchronised sources. If the active source fails or moves outside acceptable limits, the STS transfers the load to the healthy, synchronised source in approximately 2–9 ms. From the load's perspective, this arrangement resembles a high-power UPS without batteries, but the STS has no energy storage: if both sources fail, the supply stops.
CTTS without UPSSuitable for high-power loads that tolerate an interruption during a source failure but require planned transfer or retransfer without loss of power. The CTTS waits until both available sources enter the specified synchronism window, then performs closed transition.
Online UPS without a standby AC sourceSupplies power only for the calculated autonomy period. If the battery is discharged before the utility supply returns, power to the load stops.

Source transfer and maintenance arrangements around the UPS are covered on the ATS solutions for UPS systems page.

6. How to select a system

When CTTS is needed

Two high-power AC sources are available; planned transfers between sources are required without stopping the load; an interruption during a source failure is acceptable, or the critical part of the load is protected by a separate UPS.

When STS is needed

Two independent, continuously ready and synchronised sources are available; the load has a single input; emergency transfer in 2–9 ms is required. If continuous source synchronism cannot be maintained, the main advantage of the STS is lost.

When an online UPS is needed

Even a short interruption causes a shutdown, data loss or disruption to a process. The battery must provide enough autonomy to wait for the generator set to become ready or to complete a safe shutdown.

When a combination is needed

For a critical load that cannot tolerate an interruption and uses a generator set as the standby source. The ATS manages the utility and generator supplies, the UPS bridges the generator starting time and, after transfer, continues powering the load from the generator.

The right question for the design: rather than asking which device transfers faster, determine the maximum interruption each load group can tolerate and what must happen if both external sources are unavailable.

7. Five common technical misconceptions

  • “CTTS always transfers without an interruption.” No. A planned closed-transition transfer requires two sources that are simultaneously available and acceptable. The CTTS waits for them to enter the specified synchronism window and performs uninterrupted transfer at that moment. If the active source has already failed, transfer will include an interruption; if both sources are present but the window has not been reached, closed transition is delayed or inhibited according to the controller settings.
  • “STS is a type of UPS.” No. An STS is a solid-state transfer switch. It has no energy storage and cannot continue supplying the load if both power sources are absent.
  • “Electronic loads can always withstand a phase jump.” No. Switch-mode power supplies, rectifiers, inverters and variable-frequency drives can produce a high transient current and overload the STS. Guaranteed fast transfer therefore requires the STS sources to remain continuously synchronised.
  • “An online UPS takes a few milliseconds to switch to battery.” In normal double-conversion operation, the load is continuously supplied by the inverter, so transfer to battery takes 0 ms.
  • “A UPS can supply the load indefinitely after utility power fails.” No. A UPS only uses the battery's calculated energy reserve. Sustained operation requires restoration of the utility supply or connection of a generator set through the ATS.

8. Conclusion

The main difference between STS and CTTS is how and when transfer takes place. An STS must perform an emergency transfer at an unpredictable moment, so its two sources must remain continuously synchronised to guarantee transfer in 2–9 ms. Without synchronism, fast transfer is inhibited or performed with a delay; in terms of its effect on the load, the STS operates like a conventional ATS with an interruption.

A CTTS does not synchronise the sources or require them to remain continuously synchronised. For a planned closed-transition transfer, two sources must be simultaneously available and acceptable. The controller waits until the voltage, frequency and phase-angle differences enter the specified synchronism window, then briefly parallels the sources and transfers without interrupting the supply (0 ms). If one source has already failed, the CTTS transfers with an interruption. If both sources are present but the synchronism window has not been reached, closed transition is delayed or inhibited according to the controller settings.

An online UPS is not a transfer switch and should not be classified as a source-transfer device. It provides uninterrupted power using a finite energy reserve stored in its battery. In a system with an ATS and generator set, it supports the critical load while the generator starts, after which the ATS connects generator power to the UPS input.

We will select an arrangement for your facility

Send details of the power sources, load power or current and the permissible interruption duration. We will identify the appropriate architecture — CTTS, STS, an ATS with an online UPS or a combination — and prepare an engineering solution.